Pick 2 of: Hamilton, Verlander, Zobrist, Nolasco

[jewtangclan03]

So my situation isn't as obvious as it might seem by the title of the post.

12 team roto league, 5X5 (BA, R, RBI, HR, SB... W, K, ERA, WHIP, SV), 1400 innings pitched max. I've decided to keep Ellsbury (18th round), Reynolds (16th round), and Weaver (7th round). My team looks like this thus far:

C SP Weaver (7)
1B SP
2B SP
3B Reynolds (16) SP
SS SP
IF RP
OF Ellsbury (18) RP
OF RP
OF P
Util P

Every team can keep up to 5 players. Players that are drafted in the first 2 rounds cannot be kept the following year. Players can be kept for one round less (e.g. A guy you drafted in the 10th you can keep as a 9th rounder) than you drafted them the previous year. If you keep players beyond the next year, it costs 2 rounds less, then 4 rounds less in the next year, 8 rounds less the year after that, etc. Free agent pickups can be kept in the final round. And thanks in part to Grey, I won my league last year, so I'll have the 12th pick in the draft.

I'm choosing between the following players for my final 2 selections:
Hamilton ( can be kept in 4th round)
Verlander (can be kept in 5th round)
Nolasco (" " 22nd round)
Zobrist (" "24th round)

So who should it be? Lock in the studs with my 4th and 5th round picks? Take a flier on Nolasco and Zobrist with late round picks? Or perhaps one of each?

[Grey]

So my situation isn't as obvious as it might seem by the title of the post.

12 team roto league, 5X5 (BA, R, RBI, HR, SB... W, K, ERA, WHIP, SV), 1400 innings pitched max. I've decided to keep Ellsbury (18th round), Reynolds (16th round), and Weaver (7th round). My team looks like this thus far:

C SP Weaver (7)
1B SP
2B SP
3B Reynolds (16) SP
SS SP
IF RP
OF Ellsbury (18) RP
OF RP
OF P
Util P

Every team can keep up to 5 players. Players that are drafted in the first 2 rounds cannot be kept the following year. Players can be kept for one round less (e.g. A guy you drafted in the 10th you can keep as a 9th rounder) than you drafted them the previous year. If you keep players beyond the next year, it costs 2 rounds less, then 4 rounds less in the next year, 8 rounds less the year after that, etc. Free agent pickups can be kept in the final round. And thanks in part to Grey, I won my league last year, so I'll have the 12th pick in the draft.

I'm choosing between the following players for my final 2 selections:
Hamilton ( can be kept in 4th round)
Verlander (can be kept in 5th round)
Nolasco (" " 22nd round)
Zobrist (" "24th round)

So who should it be? Lock in the studs with my 4th and 5th round picks? Take a flier on Nolasco and Zobrist with late round picks? Or perhaps one of each?

Hamilton and Verlander....

[anarchy burger]

hamilton, verlander

[Malacoda]

Definitely Hamilton and Verlander.