Page 1 of 1

another draft to rate...points league people unite!

Posted: Mon Mar 25, 2013 3:22 pm
by nyphilsphan
12 teams, H2H Points CBS one keeper, 1 pt single, etc. 6 points QS, 4 Win, I had 1st overall pick and Trout was kept.

I actually sort of love my team. Those of you in points know you have to reach for 2 (or 3) starters earlier than in roto leagues, so I'm thrilled with my four top guys. I just have a few questions on roster decisions once next weekend's opening day comes - cuz none of my injured guys (except for Hughes) will be DL'd and we only have one bench spot.
1) Adam Dunn or Sandoval? It's not as quite a no-brainer in points as it would be in Roto. Most points estimate sites have Dunn equal or slightly higher (around 525 points) than Panda. Who's a Panda bounce-back believer?
2) Jesus over Perez? I'll take the homers, right?
3) AJ Burnett (the best SP FA available) over Minor?
4) I''m Defending Champ (golf clap), and although Upton burned me in round 2 last year I HAD to grab him on the turn in round FIVE.

Good luck all.

S Perez
J Montero (I)
P Goldschmidt
J Kipnis
M Cabrera
P Sandoval (I)
J Rutledge
J Bautista
J Upton
A Jackson
A Dunn
M Moore
J Zimmermann
C Hamels
Y Darvish
M Minor (R)
P Hughes (I)
J.J. Putz
A Reed

Re: another draft to rate...points league people unite!

Posted: Mon Mar 25, 2013 8:06 pm
by Mauddib
I would still take Sandoval over Dunn. Dunn strikes out too much and I like would prefer a 3B. At the very least you can trade him off.

I would rank Montero and Perez pretty similarly. Montero has more upside with the HR, I am just not sure they are all coming this year.

Minor and Burnett are pretty close. Not sure Burnett can repeat those numbers from last year and I think Minor has more upside than last year.

Re: another draft to rate...points league people unite!

Posted: Tue Mar 26, 2013 5:24 am
by nyphilsphan
Any opinion on trading Sandoval and Dunn for Ryan Howard? That would be a total home-team trade on my part, but Howard's owner is starting Pedro Alvarez and would probably bite. Thanks for the comment.