does Mendenhall belong on waivers?

[dingers]

would require dropping Donald Brown or Felix Jones to claim....

I'm thinking the 3 are all a crap shoot. ..... what do you guys think>>?

[Hebrew Hammer]

i would rank them Brown, Jones, Mendenhall right now.

I like Mendenhall but i like the others just a smidge more. Brown is clearly the best option. Jones and Mendenhall are close.

[YouthofToday]

I like Brown and Felix more. Steeler beat reporters are really critical of Mendenhall. Even if Parker goes done it probably will be a RBBC with Moore.

Brown is a stud. Addai has had 1 100 yard game in last 22 games or something like that. Indy does a hell of a job drafting (something like only 3 players on their roster weren't drafted by the organization, including Adam Vinatieri -- who doesn't count as he is a kicker... so really only 2 players).

[Doc Holliday]

I was high on Mendenhall coming into this season, but he hasn't been doing much in preseason. I think you should hold for now.