Page 1 of 1

Trade Evaluation

Posted: Sat Jul 11, 2009 5:31 pm
by Obmij76
Im in an auction keeper league and am being offered the following deal -- should I take it?

I would get:
Joe Nathan(I wont keep a closer), Chase Utley(expiring contract), Vernon Wells($4) and David Wright(expiring contract)

I give up:
Jay Bruce($5), Francisco Cordero($12), Vladimir Guerrero($18) and Mark
Reynolds($1)

Id normally take this deal in a heartbeat but the fact that I currently have Bruce and Reynolds at such a low price for what could be 3 more years, it makes me hesitant. On the other hand, the additions of Utley and Wright could push me over the top for this season.

Thoughts?

Re: Trade Evaluation

Posted: Sat Jul 11, 2009 7:05 pm
by Grey
Im in an auction keeper league and am being offered the following deal -- should I take it?

I would get:
Joe Nathan(I wont keep a closer), Chase Utley(expiring contract), Vernon Wells($4) and David Wright(expiring contract)

I give up:
Jay Bruce($5), Francisco Cordero($12), Vladimir Guerrero($18) and Mark
Reynolds($1)

Id normally take this deal in a heartbeat but the fact that I currently have Bruce and Reynolds at such a low price for what could be 3 more years, it makes me hesitant. On the other hand, the additions of Utley and Wright could push me over the top for this season.

Thoughts?
I'd take it.

Re: Trade Evaluation

Posted: Sun Jul 12, 2009 3:16 am
by Obmij76
I wasnt able to accept it in time before he pulled the offer and offered a new trade where he replaced Bruce with R. Soriano


So it's

I would get:
Joe Nathan(I wont keep a closer), Chase Utley(expiring contract), Vernon Wells($4) and David Wright(expiring contract)

I give up:
Raphael Soriano($5), Francisco Cordero($12), Vladimir Guerrero($18) and Mark Reynolds($1)


Still take it?

Re: Trade Evaluation

Posted: Sun Jul 12, 2009 8:44 am
by Grey
I wasnt able to accept it in time before he pulled the offer and offered a new trade where he replaced Bruce with R. Soriano


So it's

I would get:
Joe Nathan(I wont keep a closer), Chase Utley(expiring contract), Vernon Wells($4) and David Wright(expiring contract)

I give up:
Raphael Soriano($5), Francisco Cordero($12), Vladimir Guerrero($18) and Mark Reynolds($1)


Still take it?
I'd still take the Utley side.