Page 1 of 1

Evaluate this proposal made to me...

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 12:39 pm
by buckfever1974
I was offered Verlander and Kinsler for Utley and Shields in a H2H points league.

What pitcher would you counter with if not Shields?

My team looks like this:

C - Montero
1B - Pujols
2B - Utley
SS - Zobrist
3B - M. Cabrera
OF - B. Hamilton
OF - Pence
OF - Harper
DH - Calhoun

(My line-up is a lot better when my DL guys are active - clearly)

DL - Cargo (Coming back this weekend)
DL - Encarnacion (3 weeks)

Pitching:
Shields
Minor
Iwakuma
Lincecum
Cole
Haren
Kuroda
Niese
E. Santana
C. Martinez
Doolittle - Closer
Street - Closer

Re: Evaluate this proposal made to me...

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 1:09 pm
by buckfever1974
Or is this more fair/desirable.....

I get Kinsler & Verlander for Utley, Linceum and Calhoun . This one is more desiarable for me if for no other reason then I am going to have 5 OFs for three spots (4 if you count the DH until E5 comes back). Calhoun is expandable.

Not sure how good Calhoun could be. Harper sucks right now to.

Re: Evaluate this proposal made to me...

Posted: Thu Jul 10, 2014 4:24 pm
by Grey
I wouldn't want Verlander