Page 1 of 1

Pick 3 please help.

Posted: Tue Jan 12, 2010 7:51 pm
by greenmountaincoffee
First year of keeper league. H2H league w/QS instead of wins.

Keep 3 (1Pitcher) you give up the draft round this year for the player. I'll have the 12th pick next year.

Cabrera (Rd1)
Pedroia (Rd2)
Ichiro (Rd3)
A.Gonzalez (Rd5)
Votto (Rd7)
J.Johnson (Rd13)
Adam Jones (Rd14)
Carpenter (Rd16)
T.Hanson (Rd18)
McCutchen (Rd22)
Beckham (Rd22)

Was thinking Hanson, Cabrera, and Beckham. Scared of Carpenter w/injury and thinking I'd need to keep Cabrera to get a top10 player as I think many will likely be kept by other teams.

Thanks.

Re: Pick 3 please help.

Posted: Tue Jan 12, 2010 11:45 pm
by Grey
First year of keeper league. H2H league w/QS instead of wins.

Keep 3 (1Pitcher) you give up the draft round this year for the player. I'll have the 12th pick next year.

Cabrera (Rd1)
Pedroia (Rd2)
Ichiro (Rd3)
A.Gonzalez (Rd5)
Votto (Rd7)
J.Johnson (Rd13)
Adam Jones (Rd14)
Carpenter (Rd16)
T.Hanson (Rd18)
McCutchen (Rd22)
Beckham (Rd22)

Was thinking Hanson, Cabrera, and Beckham. Scared of Carpenter w/injury and thinking I'd need to keep Cabrera to get a top10 player as I think many will likely be kept by other teams.

Thanks.
I'd go J. Johnson, Miggy and Jones.

Re: Pick 3 please help.

Posted: Wed Jan 13, 2010 1:18 pm
by Grimlock
Keep Jones 4 rounds ahead of Hanson?! I know the arguments about pitchers and hitters you're going to make, and I disagree. If Jones were somehow proven, I would probably take him over Hanson, but he is far from it. Jones showed flashes last season, but ended the season with a sub .800 OPS and a serious injury. Hanson is easily the better bet here.

Re: Pick 3 please help.

Posted: Wed Jan 13, 2010 4:10 pm
by greenmountaincoffee
Thanks for the input. I'm also a little skeptical w/Jones as well.

Maybe Miggy, Johnson(or Hanson), and replace Jones w/McCutchen.

Probably gets 30 HR, 25-30steals, decent avg combined with Miggy and McCutch and then maybe a David Wright or Reyes to compliment that with the 13th pick.