Page 1 of 1

Good Offer? *WHIR*

Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 3:50 pm
by FromNolanToYu
Kind of worried about Lawrie and Salvy Perez.

Trade: Choo, Pence, Lawrie and Garza for R. Zimmerman, Bourne and Napoli?

Quick help in return, thanks!

12 Team H2H
C-S Perez
1B-Goldschmidt
2B-Altuve
3B-Lawrie
SS-Segura
OF-Choo
OF-McCutchen
OF-Pence
Util-Morse
BN-M Young

SP-Kershaw
SP-Miley
SP-Gio
RP-Nathan
BN-Quintana
BN-Estrada
BN-Cingrani
DL-Garza
DL-Colby

Re: Good Offer? *WHIR*

Posted: Thu Apr 25, 2013 6:11 pm
by Mauddib
I am ok with it. Both sides are giving up some decent talent that hasn't done much yet. Personally i would probably stand pat. I think I like your players more and they just need more time.

Re: Good Offer? *WHIR*

Posted: Fri Apr 26, 2013 8:20 am
by PollardsVision
Agreed. I probably wouldn't do it, but if you really don't want Lawrie, it's a fine trade.

Mostly, I wouldn't do it because I wouldn't be in a hurry to give up Choo and I'm not a huge fan of Zimm. Bourn's a great piece to have, but your team should be pretty solid in SBs anyway.

When giving up the best player in a deal (clearly Choo, imo), I'd prefer to be filling a major need and I don't think you are doing it in this case.
If Lawrie heats up, you very well might be giving up the best 2 players in this deal.