One for One trade. Can you give me your opinion? Thanks Guys

[5toolGeezy]

Thanks for the help guys! Here is the offer His Cole Hammels for my Nick Swisher. Would you pull the trigger? Considering how weak his corner IF are I think I should try to get more.. I do need a pitcher though. 12 man head to head no keeper league....THX GUYS!!! Both teams below


My Team
C- Buster Posey
1B-Miggy
2B-Orlando Cabrerra
SS- Theriot
3B- Yuke
OF-Alfonso Soriano,Holliday,Granderson
UTL- Nick Swisher
Bench- Adam Lind, Aramis Rameriez,Jay Bruce

SP- Haren, Kershaw, Nolasco,Marcum, Bondrman, Lackey
RP-Aardsma, Rauch, Gregg

HIS TEAM

C Joe Mauer
1B Garrett Jones
2B Ben Zobrist
3B David Freese
SS Marco Scutaro
OF Brad Hawpe
OF Carl Crawford
OF Chris Young
Util Marlon Byrd
BN Nelson Cruz
BN Rickie Weeks
BN Lance Berkman

SP Jon Garland
SP Chris Carpenter
RP José Valverde
RP Mariano Rivera
P CC Sabathia
P Joba Chamberlain
P Cole Hamels
BN Kevin Correia
BN Liván Hernández
DL Jorge De La Rosa

[jebusfreek666]

I wouldnt trade for hamels.... i think he is gonna fall off the map, even more than he already has. He is pitching in a big shadow now

[thepizzaman]

I'd do it. Bruce and Lind can take over that UTIL spot with no problem

[JesseBarfield]

Do it and don't look back.

[daver]

I'd make deals like that all day long ... grab Hamels while you can.

[wynams]

A mild sense of not doing the deal here. Based on belief that Swish will help your team more than Hamels for the rest of 2010.

Any chance of sending Hamels owner to the owners of Matt Cain or Ricky Nolasco and seeing if they would do 1:1's?
I'm more a believer in the two latter arms than the former and if you trust the guy enough in a gentlemen's agreement to get this 3 way deal done I think you would like it a bit better.

[Paper Tiger]

Do it.