Johan/Rolen v Gallardo/Cantu

[SilverPickles]

I have Gallardo and Cantu and was offered Johan for the pair. I'm generally sick of Gallardo, his inconsistency and his brutal walks. Rolen and Beltre are both available to add.

Should I accept and take Johan and Rolen/Beltre over Gallardo/Cantu?

[daver]

Johan has shown some inconsistency since last June too. Rolen's back worries me, but I'm not a huge Cantu fan either. I'd marginally prefer Johan/Rolen to Gallardo/Cantu, but first I'd counter with Gallardo plus a lesser player than Cantu for Johan.

[jake778]

If you can get Johan and Beltre for Gallardo and Cantu. Do it. Did you see Beltre tonight?