Page 1 of 1

12 Team 5x5 Mixed

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 8:46 pm
by rhymenoceros
First of all, I appreciate the feedback, even if you rake me across the coals. I did this draft on MDC. I know I reached for Furcal, especially after reading Rudy's point shares post. I'm also not a fan of the Jered Weaver pick. I had to take Dice-K in Rd 8 because the owner before me swooped Billingsley, which really grinds my gears. Whatever...let me know what you think.

C Ryan Doumit R10 P2
C Kelly Shoppach R23 P11
1B Lance Berkman R2 P2
1B Joey Votto R7 P11
1B Mike Jacobs R22 P2
2B Ian Kinsler R1 P11
2B Jose Lopez R15 P11
SS Rafael Furcal R6 P2
3B Mark Reynolds R20 P2
OF Jason Bay R3 P11
OF Matt Kemp R4 P2
OF Nate McLouth R5 P11
OF Adam Jones R13 P11
OF Shin-Soo Choo R18 P2
SP Daisuke Matsuzaka R8 P2
SP Javier Vazquez R12 P2
SP Johnny Cueto R16 P2
SP Jered Weaver R19 P11
RP Jonathan Broxton R9 P11
RP Francisco Cordero R11 P11
RP Max Scherzer R14 P2
RP Joey Devine R17 P11
RP Frank Francisco R21 P11

Re: 12 Team 5x5 Mixed

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:10 pm
by Steve
Weaver in the 19th is not so terrible. Point Shares has him at 87th in a 12-teamer...

Re: 12 Team 5x5 Mixed

Posted: Mon Mar 09, 2009 9:56 pm
by Grey
First of all, I appreciate the feedback, even if you rake me across the coals. I did this draft on MDC. I know I reached for Furcal, especially after reading Rudy's point shares post. I'm also not a fan of the Jered Weaver pick. I had to take Dice-K in Rd 8 because the owner before me swooped Billingsley, which really grinds my gears. Whatever...let me know what you think.

C Ryan Doumit R10 P2
C Kelly Shoppach R23 P11
1B Lance Berkman R2 P2
1B Joey Votto R7 P11
1B Mike Jacobs R22 P2
2B Ian Kinsler R1 P11
2B Jose Lopez R15 P11
SS Rafael Furcal R6 P2
3B Mark Reynolds R20 P2
OF Jason Bay R3 P11
OF Matt Kemp R4 P2
OF Nate McLouth R5 P11
OF Adam Jones R13 P11
OF Shin-Soo Choo R18 P2
SP Daisuke Matsuzaka R8 P2
SP Javier Vazquez R12 P2
SP Johnny Cueto R16 P2
SP Jered Weaver R19 P11
RP Jonathan Broxton R9 P11
RP Francisco Cordero R11 P11
RP Max Scherzer R14 P2
RP Joey Devine R17 P11
RP Frank Francisco R21 P11
You took Furcal way too early and your pitching staff is pretty suspect. It's hard to get excited about Dice-K as a number one starter and Cueto and Weaver are okay, but they're not going to anchor your staff.

EDIT: And you shouldn't have Reynolds and Jacobs on the same team, they're too similar. Balance Reynolds or Jacobs with a Loney or Conor Jackson-type.