Would You Do This Trade Or Make A Counteroffer?

[LadyScorpio]

Hey Grey!

I’m in 2nd place in a 12 team, 5x5, roto league where someone’s offered me a trade. I think it’s fair, but wondering if I should try to negotiate for something better. He’s offering D. May, K. Seager & T. Rosenthal for Z. Gallen. Bryant going on the IL does leave me with a gap to fill at 3B. Meanwhile…

His Team
C - G. Sanchez
1B - Rizzo
2B - Hiura
3B - K. Seager
SS - Mondesi
CI - Bohm
MI - E. Escobar
OF - Grichuk, K. Lewis, J.D. Matinez, V. Reyes & Trout
U - D. Smith
BN - Urshela & C. Frazier
IR - Donaldson & Bichette
SP - Glasnow, D. May, C. Burnes, G. Richards, Clevinger
RP - D. Castillo, Montero, Pressly, J. Romano & T. Rosenthal
IL - Urquidy

My Team
C - McCann
1B - Bellinger
2B - Biggio
3B - ???
SS - C. Seager
CI - R. Ruiz
MI - Cronenworth
OF - K. Calhoun, Grisham, Brantley, B. Reynolds & L. Robert
U - Myers
BN - Lux, Bryant, A. Hicks
IL - W. Smith & Judge (have REALLY missed this guy's offensive output; been in 2nd place since he got hurt)
SP - Bieber, Buehler, Fried, Gallen, Montas & Weaver
RP - Kela, Sulser & Workman
IL - Pomeranz

Do you see a better offer? Or should I take the 1 that was offered to me? Please advise.

Thanks!
LadyScorpio

[Grey]

Hey Grey!

I’m in 2nd place in a 12 team, 5x5, roto league where someone’s offered me a trade. I think it’s fair, but wondering if I should try to negotiate for something better. He’s offering D. May, K. Seager & T. Rosenthal for Z. Gallen. Bryant going on the IL does leave me with a gap to fill at 3B. Meanwhile…

His Team
C - G. Sanchez
1B - Rizzo
2B - Hiura
3B - K. Seager
SS - Mondesi
CI - Bohm
MI - E. Escobar
OF - Grichuk, K. Lewis, J.D. Matinez, V. Reyes & Trout
U - D. Smith
BN - Urshela & C. Frazier
IR - Donaldson & Bichette
SP - Glasnow, D. May, C. Burnes, G. Richards, Clevinger
RP - D. Castillo, Montero, Pressly, J. Romano & T. Rosenthal
IL - Urquidy

My Team
C - McCann
1B - Bellinger
2B - Biggio
3B - ???
SS - C. Seager
CI - R. Ruiz
MI - Cronenworth
OF - K. Calhoun, Grisham, Brantley, B. Reynolds & L. Robert
U - Myers
BN - Lux, Bryant, A. Hicks
IL - W. Smith & Judge (have REALLY missed this guy's offensive output; been in 2nd place since he got hurt)
SP - Bieber, Buehler, Fried, Gallen, Montas & Weaver
RP - Kela, Sulser & Workman
IL - Pomeranz

Do you see a better offer? Or should I take the 1 that was offered to me? Please advise.

Thanks!
LadyScorpio

Hmm, is this a keeper? If so, I'd hold...If not, Seager at least fixes your 3B problem and sending Gallen isn't terrible with only a month+ left -- not liek May is bad