Page 1 of 1

Rank these QBs for rest of season

Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2010 4:57 pm
by The Peoples Champ
Drafted Kolb as my starter in 2 leagues. There are a few options out there, and I feel they are generally on the same level. How would everyone rank these guys for the rest of the season and why? Just looking for top 3...

Garrard
Orton
Alex Smith
Vick
Campbell

I'm leaning Vick, Orton, Smith. Vick's dual threat puts him slightly above Orton and Smith. Orton and Smith have the better options around them. I'm expecting Vick to be claimed off waivers before me in both leagues, so it's down to those 2. I liked Smith better on draft day, but right now it's a toss up IMO. Any and all opinions appreciated.

Re: Rank these QBs for rest of season

Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2010 5:04 pm
by jebusfreek666
if vick starts he would be top.... but until then he will be on the bottom. then orton, smith, garrard, and campbell

Re: Rank these QBs for rest of season

Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2010 5:05 pm
by nyphilsphan
Probably put Orton/Vick even depending on matchup. Thank your lucky stars you're not like me in a 2QB league with Kolb. Pickings are SLIM.

Re: Rank these QBs for rest of season

Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2010 6:32 pm
by The Peoples Champ
Probably put Orton/Vick even depending on matchup. Thank your lucky stars you're not like me in a 2QB league with Kolb. Pickings are SLIM.
My 2 QB league I drafted Brady, Campbell, and Garrard. Yesterday evening I proposed Garrard, Best, and Bradshaw for Charles and Kolb. Luckily, the trade was not yet accepted or rejected, and I was able to cancel it.

One league is a keeper (get 1 player for $10 more than the previous season, protect 2). Figured Kolb would be a good $11 guy next year. The other I drafted Smith and dropped him for Garrard for a 1 week fill in (WHO GETS PULLED AGAINST SD DEFENSE!?!?).

With McNabb as my starting QB in the keeper league, and no limit on transactions, i'm not going to be heartbroken if Vick loses the job.

With Garrard as my only other QB in a league with a 10 transaction limit (already used 2 on Garrard and Mike Sims-Walker who was dropped!) i'm thinking Orton might be a little safer with a ceiling that's about the same. Still a possibility that they start losing and Tebow is thrown in. Still not very confident either way... Any other suggestions?