Razzball.com Forums

Accept. The guy is overreacting to the early seasons stats.

Reyes is turning 29 in June. Go look at Rollins' numbers after the age of 28 and then tell me if you really want to trade in a keeper league for a 29 year-old whose value primarily comes from speed.

Where do they stand? Are we talking future 1st round upside with Hosmer or is he more of a 30 HR ceiling, Morneau-at-his-peak type player?

Plus Trout runs like the wind (err...swims like the rapids?) 33/43 SB in the minors, 4/4 in the majors last year. I think this guy could be Ellsbury except healthy...All's-wellsbury.

My lineup is this:

V-Mart
Teixeira
Scott Sizemore
A-Rod
Hanley
OF 1-J Upton
OF 2- BJ Upton
OF 3- Heyward
UT - Bruce
BN - Gardner

We keep any 6 from year to year. I'd like to upgrade at 2B but I think Bruce is too valuable in a keeper. Thoughts?

The Utley side is taking a big risk, but if he comes back healthy he is more valuable than Youkilis. I wouldn't take the Utley side of the trade personally, but I don't think it's outrageous.

I don't own CarGo anywhere, I do own A-Rod in a keeper. I'd be patient with CarGo. A-Rod was just complaining about his hip this week, and at his age I don't think he's someone you should be paying full dollar for.

In a league with OPS and holds, I'd do it. Especially if it's H2H and you can stream a little bit. Starting pitchers aren't nearly as valuable.

A great first week had me thinking that this is a bounceback year for Beckham. Now I'm ready to dump him after he's gone about 2 for his last 50.

Someone talk me down from the ledge or tell me who I should pick up to replace him from this list:

Freddy Sanchez
Theriot
Espinosa
Aviles
Herrera

I need to pick my last two keepers from this group of players:

BJ Upton
Victor Martinez
Francisco Liriano
Neftali Feliz


First four keepers:
Hanley
A-Rod
Teixieira
Justin Upton